Others

Which Motor is Used in Electric Vehicles?

Written by

...

Electric Vehicles (EVs) are the future revolutionized automotive industry by offering a cleaner and more ecologically responsible electric alternative to the gas- or oil-based internal combustion engine option. The critical element in an EV is the electric motor, which transforms electric power into mechanical power that propels the Sulfur Cove.

Even the Vehicle Technologies Office of the U.S. Department of Energy supports research and development to improve motor quality, which will also be used for hybrid and plug-in electric vehicles. These vehicles reduce petroleum consumption, but if they use engine-driven generators, then they only provide performance at the cost of emissions. Types of motors used in electric vehicles, the way they work, the advantages and disadvantages, etc., will be discussed in detail here.

Which Motor is Used in Electric Vehicles

What types of Motors are used in Electric Vehicles?

Electric vehicles are changing how humans drive, and they have less waste when driven on the road as they tend to be more nature-friendly. The critical element is an electric motor, a unit aimed to transform electrical energy into mechanical energy required to move. Because electric vehicle engines are developing and expanding, knowing more about their technical specifications and differences is essential. So, the VTO’s mission is to reduce electric motor cost, volume, and weight while maintaining or improving electric vehicles’ performance, efficiency, and reliability. For the research to reach the 2022 target cost, the cost of motors must be reduced by 50%; it was the VTO’s last projection. To ensure this happens, VTO focuses on reducing the use of rare earth materials in permanent magnet-based motors. 

1. Brushless DC Motors (BLDC):

Among EV’s most popular electric motor types are Brushless DC motors, electronically commutated DC motors, and Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors. The advantages of BLCD motors include a high power-to-weight ratio and excellent speed control, which makes them a suitable option for smaller EVs and even two-wheelers since they can quickly adapt to the compact size and maintain effectiveness. Other advantages of this electric motor include high efficiency, low maintenance requirement, good heat dissipation, and others. The disadvantages of the BLDC type include higher prices than others because using permanent magnets requires complex control systems.

2. Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors (PMSM)

PMSM motors are similar to BLDC motors. It usually has higher efficiency and power-dense characteristics. Instead of using current coils, PMSMs utilize permanent magnets. Unlike BLDC, these motors have a more complex structure. PMSM motors have a sinusoidal back electromotive force and are thus smoother than other types of electric motors. However, using scarce magnets in such an engine type makes it more expensive than other forms. PMSM motors are also more power-dense and provide more precise control.

3. Induction Motors (IM):

Induction Motors, or asynchronous motors, have been used in various industrial and consumer applications for decades. These motors have several advantages, including rugged construction, reliability, and lower cost, compared to BLDC and PMSM. Induction motors work based on electromagnetic induction and do not contain permanent magnets. An induction motor is a crucial part of numerous larger EVs, where the motor’s cost and ruggedness properties yield even more benefits. 

Key advantages: 

a)  Rugged construction b) High reliability c) Lower cost d) Applicability in harsh environments

Key Disadvantages:

a) Lower efficiency compared to BLDC and PMSM b) The need for more sophisticated control. 

4. Switched Reluctance Motors:

Switched reluctance motors are gaining popularity among EV manufacturers for their simple, rugged construction and absence of permanent magnets. This engine type works with a toothed rotor and stator; coil windings are placed around each stator’s teeth. Energizing the coils in a specific pattern creates the essential reluctance that makes the rotor deviate toward the stator’s teeth, generating torque. SRMs do not entail using permanent magnets, reducing costs, and solving availability issues related to rare earth elements. Additional advantages include good operational efficiency at various speeds and a fault-tolerant design. However, higher vibration characteristics can make these motors noisier and less stable. 

Key advantages: 

a) Simple, rugged construction. b) No need for permanent magnets c) High-speed capability. d) Simple fault tolerance. 

Key Disadvantages: 

a) Low torque density, b) Noise and vibrations. 

5. Synchronous Reluctance Motors:

This is the first type of reluctance motor that combines the best qualities of both permanent magnet and inductor types. These motors have a rotor design that does not involve magnets, operating solely on the reform principle. SynRMs are suitable for their efficient use and lack expensive or environmentally hazardous materials. These motors are getting more attention because they compromise between customer demand and stakes.

What are the Factors for Selection of Motors for an EV?

Choosing the motor for an electric vehicle is critical, as it impacts every aspect of performance, efficiency, and driver satisfaction. Given the rapid development of electric vehicle technology and the growing number of models on the market, it is crucial to understand the surrounding factors and considerations. Therefore, choosing the appropriate motor is vital for optimizing the performance, efficiency, and driving experience of an EV. Even the Indian government’s F1 Accelerated Manufacturing of Electric Vehicles in India FAME-II scheme 2019 offers incentives to different types of electric vehicles for India; incentives are different based on battery size and all. For example, two-wheelers can receive Rs 15000/- per kWh, up to 40% of the vehicle cost for approximately 2 kWh. This guide offers an extensive overview of the primary considerations that affect the decisions related to the motor as a critical component of an EV.

1. Performance requirements:

 As expected, the choice of motor starts from the EV’s performance requirement. It includes power, torque, speed, and speed-up abilities. In ideal conditions, motors differ in how much they can produce. For instance, powerful electric vehicles use Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors with high density and efficiency, which allows them to accelerate fast and reach high-top speeds.

2. Efficiency and range:

Efficiency is another primary concern when choosing a suitable motor, as it determines the overall range. Motors with a higher efficiency level are more productive in converting the electrical power received from the battery and transforming it into mechanical energy to move the vehicle. According to Sadeghzadeh et al. Motions, PMSMs, and Induction motors offer some of the best efficiencies in the market. ChoongLeong et al. also added Inferior Permanent Magnet Motors to the list; as for the battery, they could run the car over the same as the scavenger motors. Cost. Finally, the cost of the motor itself should be considered. PMSMs represent a prime choice with a high demand and price. The motor’s key features are high efficiency and performance.

3. Size and weight:

The motor’s size and weight will affect the EV’s design and dynamics. Looking for motors with a high power-to-weight ratio is preferable, meaning you get the desired output without adding unnecessary weight or occupying too much space. This is especially critical for small gadgets where space is scarce. 

4. Thermal Management:

The motor’s thermal management solution is critical. It’s essential to search for quality motors with adequate thermal dissipation. Avoid motors that frequently operate at high temperatures because they will lose efficiency and degrade faster. Motors will likely work under the hood and in the rain for extended periods unless the EV is intended solely for studio experimentation.

Furthermore, ensure it is robust and can withstand stressful, high-speed requirements. Durability and design are two more things to consider. The motor you buy should have a soft delivery and few repairs, maintenance, and upkeep. BLDC and PMSM have fewer parts that can wear out and are generally best for ownership and long-lasting satisfaction. Finally, the motor must be accompanied by a smooth EV drive and battery balance to ensure optimum efficiency.

5. Power Density and Efficiency:

Power density is a term used to describe the amount of power the motor generates within a set volume or weight. Ideally, the motor with high power density would generate the most power with the least volume consumed. The motor needs to have good power density since space is limited in an electric vehicle. In addition, the motor’s efficiency is also a critical factor since it directly influences a vehicle’s driving range and energy consumption. 

PMSMs and BLDCs are considered efficient motors because they use permanent magnets in their rotors, which help in the electromagnetic field produced by the stator windings. The BLDC and PMSM are similar in construction since both types use permanent magnets in the rotor. At the same time, the stator windings are employed to create a reverse rotating field to which the permanent magnets react, causing the rotor to rotate. 

6. Torque Characteristics:

 The term torque characteristics implies that the motor needs to produce a high torque at a low speed to perform well when the driver accelerates the vehicle or drives uphill. However, the torque must also remain consistent across a target range when the driver maintains the desired speed to optimize battery life. 

Induction motors, also known as the asynchronous motor, would be ideal for the previous application. It is a standard motor whose high current in the stator windings induces a current in the motor bars.

EV ModelMotor TypeKey FeaturesMeritDemerit
Tesla Model SAC Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors (PMSM)a) High efficiency

b) Simple design

c) Regenerative braking
a) Excellent performance

b) Low maintenance

c) Long range
a) Higher cost compared to DC motors.

b) Requires complex control systems
Nissan LeafPermanent Magnet Synchronous Motor (PMSM)a) Single motor, front-wheel drive

b) Compact and lightweight design

c) Regenerative braking for improved range
a) Excellent torque density

b) Smaller and lighter than induction motors

c) Precise control
a) Requires rare earth permanent magnets.

b) Higher manufacturing costs
Chevrolet BoltPermanent Magnet Synchronous Motora) Single motor, front-wheel drive

b) High power density and efficiency

c) Integrated with a single-speed transmission
a) High power-to-weight ratio

b) Smooth operation

c) Precise speed control
a) Dependence on rare earth materials.

b) Increased cost due to permanent magnets
BMW i3Hybrid Synchronous Motora) Combines permanent magnet and induction motor technologies.

b) Compact and lightweight design

c) Efficient power delivery and regenerative braking
a) Balanced performance

b) Lower reliance on scarce materials

c) Smooth and efficient operation
a) More complex design than single motor types

b) Potentially higher manufacturing costs
Hyundai Kona ElectricPermanent Magnet Synchronous Motora) Single motor, front-wheel drive

b) High torque output for responsive acceleration.

c) Liquid-cooled for optimal thermal management.

d) Smooth acceleration 
a) Dynamic performance in both high and low-speed operation.  

b) High power density and low rotor inertia.  

c) No torque ripple.
 
d) High efficiency at high speeds, resistant to wear and tear.

e) Available in small sizes at different packages, easy maintenance and installation.

f) Capable of maintaining full torque at low speeds, high reliability, dissipating heat and less noise factors.
Initial cost is high and very expensive compared to other motor types.   Difficult to start up.
Audi e-tronAsynchronous Motorsa) Dual motor configuration for all-wheel drive

b) Smooth and quiet operation

c) Efficient power delivery and regenerative braking
a) Affordable

b) Reliable

c) Suitable for front motor in AWD systems
a) Increased cooling requirements

b) Lower efficiency compared to synchronous motors
Jaguar I-PACETwo Synchronous Permanent Magnet Electric Motorsa) Dual motor configuration for all-wheel drive

b) Instant Torque

c) Regenerative Braking
a) High Performance

b) Highly efficient, with up to 97% efficiency in power transfer.

c) Smooth and quiet driving experience.
a) High expensive due to the use of rare-earth materials.  
b) Supply Chain Constraints
Volkswagen ID.4single RWD powertrain and dual AWD)powertrain motora) A single RWD provides a balanced and efficient driving experience for everyday use.

b) Double AWD delivers enhanced traction and stability.

c) Smooth and quiet ride, emphasizing comfort and refinement.
a) Instant torque delivery

b) The electric powertrain requires less maintenance compared to traditional internal combustion engines.
a) It includes some low-quality cabin plastics.

b) Some controls and informational features in the ID.4 can be challenging to operate.

c) It is less sporty or fun to drive than its competitor EVs.
Ford Mustang Mach-EPermanent Magnet Synchronous Motorsa) High torque density

b) Efficient power delivery

c) Regenerative braking capability Compact design
a) PMSM provides excellent low-speed torque

b) The motor’s efficiency contributes to a more extended driving range on a single charge.

c)High smooth acceleration.

d) The compact nature of the motor allows for more cabin or cargo space.  
a) High expensive due to the use of rare-earth materials.

b) The precise control algorithms are needed in the motors.  

Hello everyone, my name is Debash Biswas. I am a support engineer in an automobile manufacturing company, which makes me more helpful in writing content because I also have good knowledge about car manufacturing companies. I have also been working as a content writer since 2021. My hobbies are riding a car, reading books, reading newspapers, etc. If you liked my article, please share it with your friends. You can follow me on Twitter and Facebook. Thanks to all readers.

Leave a comment