Electric Vehicles

2024 Tesla Model Y vs Model 3- Which Should You Buy?

Written by

...

A potential Tesla car buyer often gets caught up in the dilemma of either the Tesla Model Y or the Tesla Model 3. While both vehicles boast impressively, they remain distinct in catering to varied needs or preferences. This post provides an all-inclusive comparison of the two leading electric cars to guide you in making an informed choice.

2024 Tesla Model Y vs Model 3

Is Model 3 better than Model Y?

It depends on your needs and the priorities you value. Model 3 has some advantages regarding efficiency, range, and driving dynamics. A lighter, more aerodynamic car gets more miles from the same battery pack. According to the support team interaction, the latest “Tesla Model 3” has a HEPA air filter that effectively adsorbs harmful particles and gases. It is installed below the passenger seat. The handling efficiency is better due to a lower center of gravity, and in the turns, it seems more “sporty.” If we are talking about the car’s compactness in terms of space and versatility, the Tesla Model Y has an advantage over it. Nevertheless, the Model Y shows itself in terms of space and practicality. 

Where the Model Y does shine is in terms of space and flexibility. It has substantially more cargo space, offering 76 cubic feet when you fold the rear flat rather than the Model 3’s 43.6 cubic feet. The Model Y also has an optional third row, making the total passenger capacity seven. So, if you have enough people and stuff to drive around, the Model Y will be the more functional and functional car.

Despite the Model Y’s designation as the best-selling car in the world, Tesla’s sales have decreased by 18% year-on-year to 31,379 in April 2024. Additionally, it was reported that the EV market had increased 4% year-on-year but at the slowest rate in the past year. So, If you need to buy Tesla Model Y or Model 3, you need to people’s review and sales growth etc.

Speculation also suggests that the Model Y may receive a substantial update as early as Q2 2024, incorporating many features from the 2024 Model 3. There is no indication that this will happen, but the time element is important when doing a comparison as buyers will have to weigh the benefits of purchasing a refreshed 3 model against waiting for the updated Y model.

Tesla Model Y vs Tesla Model 3 Features Details

FeatureTesla Model YTesla Model 3
Vehicle TypeCompact crossover SUVCompact sedan
Seating CapacityUp to 7 passengers with optional 3rd rowUp to 5 passengers
Range (EPA est.)Long Range: 330 miles, Performance: 303 milesStandard Range Plus: 263 miles, Long Range: 353 miles, Performance: 315 miles
0-60 mph AccelerationLong Range: 4.8 sec, Performance: 3.5 secStandard Range Plus: 5.3 sec, Long Range: 4.2 sec, Performance: 3.1 sec
Top Speed135 mph (217 km/h)140 mph (225 km/h) for Performance, 145 mph (233 km/h) for Long Range
Cargo Space68 cu ft (1.9 m³) with seats folded15 cu ft (425 L) trunk
Ground Clearance6.6 inches (167 mm)5.5 inches (140 mm)
DrivetrainDual Motor All-Wheel DriveRear-Wheel Drive (Standard Range Plus), Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive (Long Range & Performance)
Supercharging Max Rate250 kW250 kW
Dimensions (L x W x H)187″ L x 76″ W x 64″ H185″ L x 73″ W x 57″ H
Pricing (USD)Long Range: $52,990, Performance: $60,990Standard Range Plus: $39,990, Long Range: $48,990, Performance: $56,990

In a short time, the Model Y has become Tesla’s highest-selling car for various reasons. The SUV body style, a blend of crossover design elements, manages to strike a balance in size. It does not compromise on space within the vehicle— offering a generously roomy interior and adaptable cargo capacity — yet also does not feel overly large or cumbersome. Moreover, the elevated seating position allows drivers to enjoy an unobstructed view of their surroundings from a perspective many find preferable.

On top of its own merits, the Model Y reaps further benefits due to being associated with Tesla’s already-established brand image and technology advancements. Equipped by default with Autopilot assistance for drivers through sophisticated onboard sensors plus computing capabilities, it also features a 15-inch touch display that provides access to various controls and infotainment options that are wirelessly updatable. As well as through software updates received over-the-air using mobile data networks without needing physical connections or visits back at service centers; this model additionally gets power from Tesla’s Supercharger network with high-speed charging stations available nationwide. 

All these state-of-the-art technological perks make Tesla’s electric SUV more alluring since it delivers outstanding performance and an aerodynamic zero-emission propulsion system typically expected from such vehicles presented by this automaker at the forefront.

Is Model 3 as safe as Model Y?

To evaluate the safety of Tesla’s Model 3 and Model Y, popular electric cars in the market, one must consider several safety elements and factors contributing to their safety ratings and real-world performance. The two models come with some of the most advanced safety features and have been tested extensively for their compliance with high safety requirements. The paragraphs above have provided an in-depth review of their features, testing outcomes, and practical implications.

Comprehensive Safety Testing

Given their excellent performance, both the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y models participated in tests conducted by the U.S. regulatory authorities: the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Thus, some of the most notable results the two Teslas received are the following: 

  • NHTSA Ratings: The NHTSA gave both the model 3 and the model Y a 5-star safety rating. The best thing about a five-star safety ranking is that it is awarded based on a car’s performance in various evaluations. In the area of performance in front-end crashes, side accidents, and rollover crashes, both vehicles received high marks. 
  • IIHS Evaluations: The IIHS Top Safety Pick+ award was given to the Model Y. According to various crash tests, including the strict small frontal overlap test, the TSP+ honor is awarded to the safest possible car. While the Model 3 has sometimes been awarded the TSP+ award in previous years, it was not nominated in 2023 and 2024 since it had not yet met the latest standards.

Structural Integrity and Design Innovations

Both Model 3 and Model Y place a strong emphasis on structural safety. Some of the features engineered with this in mind to achieve crashworthiness and structural integrity include: – 

1. Robust vehicle architecture: 

Model 3 and Model Y strongly emphasize adequate occupant protection. Moreover, Model Y benefits from a slightly larger frame and a higher ride height. It could offer better visibility and perhaps even safety in particular collisions.

2. Advanced crumple zones:

The Tesla vehicle’s crumple zones can effectively absorb and dissipate much of the energy generated in a collision. As a result, the impact on occupants is significantly mitigated. 

3. Reinforced battery pack:

The Model Y could also benefit from a reinforced battery pack that contributes to the vehicle’s structural strength, thus reducing battery risks.

Cutting-Edge Safety Features

Tesla had state-of-the-art safety features. Numerous cutting-edge safety technologies in the Model 3 and Model Y help prevent accidents and save passengers’ lives. This includes autopilot and active pedestrian protection. Initially, both models come equipped with Tesla’s Autopilot systems, features cantered on Automatic Emergency Braking, Lane Departure Warning, and Forward Collision Warning. All these systems use complex sensors and cameras to enhance situational awareness and intervention capabilities. Since new safety standards consider not only the safety of passengers in a vehicle but also the safety of everyone else on the road, even pedestrian protection tests are becoming increasingly important. The Model Y performs exceptionally well in pedestrian protection.

Safety insights from the real world:

In addition to the laboratory test, the real-world safety behaviour of the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y offers the following insights:

1. Low injury risk: According to Tesla’s safety statistics, the Model 3 and Model Y are some cars with the lowest injury probabilities of all the vehicles the NHTSA has tested. This indicates the efficacy of the vehicle’s design and safety measures. 

2. Rollover probability: Due to the vehicle’s low centre of gravity, the Model Y is less likely to roll over, an issue that plagues vertically built vehicles. The car’s stability is vital as it does not capsize during an emergency crash or hard cornering. 

3. Survivability in extreme conditions: Though few, there have been scenarios where the Model Y has saved the occupants from catastrophic accidents. For instance, the car protected the occupants following a freefall off a high cliff. This demonstrates that the car’s safety measures ensure the occupants remain safe.

Is Model Y louder than Model 3?

Concerns similar to those of many conventional buyers about buying a Tesla car include perceived noise comfort inside a vehicle. As such, either Tesla Model Y or Model 3 might interest a buyer who is more unsure about the quieter model. Understanding the differences in cabin noise between these popular vehicles can play a crucial role in choosing one. 

1. Design/Aerodynamics:

The Model Y has a body profile that differs from the Model 3 in that it is a compact SUV, making the frontal part more significant compared to Model 3, which is compact and streamlined. The difference will often imply that Model Y has less aerodynamic efficiency and will have more noise in the vehicle. 

Tesla, however, applies sound mitigation techniques that do not allow the air noise that results from the frontal part of the car to impact inside the vehicle. Tesla technology has, therefore, ensured that facial air resistance does not affect the amount of noise in the vehicle. 

2. Cabin insulation/build quality:

Tesla has made regular and active efforts to take better vehicle construction. This recent model has, therefore, improved the model for both Model Y and 3 to be less noisy. Due to the bigger size of Model Y, the number of noise-prevention tools applied to it is more than what is installed in Model 3. For instance, the Model 3 has a better cabin than Model Y due to its smaller volume to manage and control noise. 

3. Road Noise:

An additional factor that people must consider relies on the wheel type and the tire. Model Y and 3 have different wheel sizes as well as types of tires. The wheels play a role in the amount of noise on the road due to the size of the tires, the more significant the wheel, the more noise. However, Tesla has technologies in silence production that they install as their tire company, reducing road noise. The specific road conditions will also influence road noise. 

4. User Experience:

Under this factor, Model 3 is preferred because of its arrangement and background technology introduced in its system. Though both cars are silent, Model 3 tends to be more comfortable than Y.

Users Reviews about Tesla Model Y vs Model 3

Tesla Model Y vs Model 3

Hello everyone, my name is Debash Biswas. I am a support engineer in an automobile manufacturing company, which makes me more helpful in writing content because I also have good knowledge about car manufacturing companies. I have also been working as a content writer since 2021. My hobbies are riding a car, reading books, reading newspapers, etc. If you liked my article, please share it with your friends. You can follow me on Twitter and Facebook. Thanks to all readers.

Leave a comment