As we have seen in the previous blog posts, Hydrogen powered cars are very rare now a days because it is in the starting phase as of now. Hydrogen as a traditional fuel is yet to be tested in the real world that’s why a major question arises regarding its safety measures, people are very much concerned about the usage and safety aspects of hydrogen fuel. In this article we will go through several comparisons and explanations about Hydrogen Cars and we will also know how safe is hydrogen powered cars are from traditional cars.
Table of Contents
SAFETY RATINGS
Here’s a table based on the safety ratings of different types of fuel powered cars-
Vehicle Type | NHTSA Safety Rating | Euro NCAP Safety Rating |
Hydrogen FCEVs | 5-star overall rating | 5-star overall rating |
Gasoline ICE Vehicles | 4-5 star overall rating | 4-5 star overall rating |
Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs) | 5-star overall rating | 5-star overall rating |
The safety data provided reflects the advancements in vehicle technology and safety standards across different powertrain types. Hydrogen FCEVs and BEVs consistently achieve 5-star overall ratings from both NHTSA and Euro NCAP, highlighting their cutting-edge safety features, structural integrity, and crashworthiness. In contrast, gasoline ICE vehicles show a range of 4-5 stars, indicating that while many models still meet high safety standards, there is variability due to older technologies and designs in some models. This demonstrates the increasing emphasis on safety in modern, eco-friendly vehicle technologies like FCEVs and BEVs.
SAFETY FEATURES-
Here’s a table comparing the safety features of Hydrogen FCEVs, Gasoline ICE Vehicles, and Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs):
Feature | Hydrogen FCEVs | Gasoline ICE Vehicles | Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs) |
Crash Safety (NHTSA & Euro NCAP) | 5-star rating (Both agencies) | 4-5 star rating (Both agencies) | 5-star rating (Both agencies) |
Fuel Flammability | Low flammability (hydrogen disperses quickly) | High flammability (gasoline highly combustible) | Low flammability (lithium-ion battery risk) |
Explosion Risk | Low (hydrogen tanks designed to withstand impact) | High (gasoline can explode in severe crashes) | Low (battery short-circuit or thermal runaway) |
Leak Detection | Advanced sensors for hydrogen leak detection | Basic sensors for gasoline leak detection | Advanced sensors for battery temperature/pressure |
Structural Safety | High-strength hydrogen tanks (carbon fibre) | Reinforced fuel tanks, crumple zones | Reinforced battery compartments, crumple zones |
Toxic Emissions | None (zero emissions) | High (carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides) | None (zero tailpipe emissions) |
Thermal Management | Advanced cooling systems for fuel cells | Limited cooling for engine | Advanced thermal management for batteries |
Post-Crash Safety | Immediate hydrogen venting to prevent fire risk | Risk of fire due to gasoline spill | Risk of battery fire; systems designed to contain it |
This table illustrates how hydrogen FCEVs, gasoline vehicles, and BEVs compare in terms of safety features, with FCEVs and BEVs generally offering more advanced safety mechanisms, especially concerning fuel management and post-crash scenarios.Hydrogen FCEVs prioritise safety with advanced features such as high-strength, impact-resistant hydrogen tanks and sensors for leak detection. Hydrogen’s low flammability, combined with its rapid dispersion, reduces fire risk. In the event of a crash, hydrogen venting systems further minimise explosion hazards. These vehicles also produce no toxic emissions, enhancing both environmental and passenger safety.
Here is a risk comparison among all type of fuel powered cars-
Data Table: Risk Comparison
Risk Factor | Hydrogen Cars (FCEVs) | Gasoline Cars (ICE) | Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs) |
Fire Risk | Low (Hydrogen disperses quickly) | High (Gasoline highly flammable) | Medium (Risk of thermal runaway in batteries) |
Explosion Risk | Low (Venting system in case of leak) | Medium to High (Gasoline vapors) | Low (Battery explosion is rare) |
Fuel Leak Risk | Low (Sensors and rapid dispersion) | Medium (Gasoline can spill in crashes) | None (No combustible fuel) |
Post-Crash Risk | Low (Hydrogen venting to prevent hazards) | High (Gasoline spills increase fire risk) | Medium (Battery fire can occur post-crash) |
Toxic Emissions | None (Zero emissions) | High (Carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides) | None (Zero tailpipe emissions) |
This table highlights the overall lower risk profile of hydrogen cars compared to gasoline-powered vehicles, while BEVs also pose minimal risks but can experience unique battery-related issues.
Global Incident Statistics for Hydrogen FCEVs:
- Total Hydrogen FCEVs in operation: Around 10,000+ as of 2022
- Total reported incidents: Approximately 50-60 since 2000
- Incident rate: On average, around 0.5-0.6% of all hydrogen FCEVs
Breakdown of Reported Incidents:
- Fires: 10-15 cases, representing 20-30% of incidents
- Explosions: 5-7 cases, accounting for 10-14% of incidents
- Leaks: 15-20 cases, making up 30-40% of incidents
- Electrical Issues: 5-10 cases, covering 10-20% of incidents
- Other (e.g., crashes, mechanical failures): 10-15 cases, contributing 20-30% of incidents
Noteworthy Incidents:
- 2019: A hydrogen fuel cell bus caught fire in South Korea. Thankfully, no injuries were reported.
- 2018: A Toyota Mirai FCEV experienced a fire in California, USA, but again, no injuries occurred.
- 2015: A fuel leak was detected in a Honda Clarity FCEV in Japan; no injuries reported.
- 2014: A Hyundai ix35 FCEV caught fire in South Korea with no injuries reported.
Comparison to Other Vehicle Types:
- Gasoline Internal Combustion Engine Vehicles (ICEVs): Around 170,000 fires reported annually, affecting 0.012% of total gasoline vehicles.
- Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs): Roughly 100 fires occur annually, impacting less than 0.005% of the total BEV population.
Sources Referenced:
- International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF)
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)
- Euro NCAP
- Hydrogen Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle Safety Report (2020)
- Multiple industry reports and news sources
Important Considerations:
- Incident statistics for hydrogen FCEVs are relatively sparse due to the limited number of these vehicles on the road.
- Variability exists in how incidents are classified and reported across different regions and sources.
- These statistics provide a general perspective rather than a detailed or exhaustive analysis.
Although hydrogen fuel cell is very safe but there are some risk factors-
- Flammability: Hydrogen is highly flammable, and while it disperses quickly in open spaces, any leaks in confined areas can create fire hazards if ignited.
- Storage and Transport: Storing hydrogen requires high-pressure tanks, which pose risks of leaks or ruptures, especially if the tanks are damaged.
- Explosion Risk: While rare, if hydrogen is contained and ignites, it can lead to powerful explosions, particularly in the presence of oxygen.
- Hydrogen Leaks: Hydrogen is colorless and odorless, making leaks harder to detect without proper sensors, which could increase fire risks.
- Infrastructure Vulnerabilities: Hydrogen fueling infrastructure is still developing, and mishandling during refueling or transport could lead to safety issues.
CONCLUSION
Hydrogen FCEVs have a solid safety track record, often matching or even surpassing that of traditional fuel-powered vehicles. While there are inherent risks, these are significantly reduced through cutting-edge safety technologies and thoughtful design.
Related Posts
Can You Drink Water from Hydrogen Cars?
We always wonder about how things work,our curiosity drives us…
How Safe Are Hydrogen Cars?
As we have seen in the previous blog posts, Hydrogen…
Is Hydrogen gas Highly Explosive?
As we have discussed about the hydrogen fuel cell in…
How Expensive Are Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicles?
Today, fuel cell vehicles are more expensive than battery electric…
Is Hydrogen Fuel Cheaper Than Gasoline?
As currently we know that all of the major vehicles…
How Hydrogen Fuel Cell Car Works?
A fuel-cell electric vehicle (FCEV) is a new, clean vehicle…